Imagine you have just published your first book, and the first comment you read on social media is a scathing review. Upsetting and demotivating, right? Your first instinct might be to respond with equal intensity. Yet, this is the biggest mistake an author can make. So, how should an author handle criticism of their writing? You may feel panicked because the book you have written is close to your heart, and the criticism feels personal. You perceive it as an attack on your craft, which can impact book sales. For any author, gracefully handling negative reviews is an essential skill.
Whether you’re a debut writer or a seasoned author, navigating critical book reviews with dignity and wisdom can turn setbacks into opportunities. Here are a few strategies for handling negative book reviews.
1. Accept That Criticism Is Inevitable
Some criticism is inevitable in a market filled with readers who have diverse views. Not every reader will appreciate your writing style, your story, or even the situations presented in the book. Some may remain silent about their dislikes, while others will be outspoken and vocal.
Example: Well-known authors like Arundhati Roy, a Booker Award recipient, also receive negative book reviews! The very popular Chetan Bhagat also faces criticism. It helps to know you are not the only author out there who faces critical book reviews. The trick is to figure out how to handle book critics’ reviews constructively.
Writing is an art, and like all art, it is subjective. Not everyone will love your book, and that is perfectly okay. The diversity of opinions is what makes the literary world so rich and interesting. Understanding this can help you handle negative book reviews and also book critics’ reviews with a more open mind.
2. Read the Review Objectively
When you receive a review, look at it objectively without letting your emotions rule. Consider whether the review is constructive. Point out where you may have erred, like inconsistencies in the story or character development, and consider their feedback as a learning opportunity. However, if the review is baseless or purely negative without substance, don’t dwell on it.
Pro Tip: Separate emotional critiques from constructive criticism. If a critic reviews your book saying, “This book is horrible!”, that’s not helpful. But if they say, “The pacing in the second half slows down, which affects engagement,” then that’s something worth considering. Constructive criticism points out specific areas for improvement, while hate comments are purely negative and often lack substance.
3. Engage Wisely or Stay Silent
Not every bad book review requires a response. If a reviewer raises valid points, like a weakness in the plot or inconsistent chronology, thank the reviewer for their feedback. If a reviewer gives emotional feedback, like “a horrible book, ” such feedback can be ignored, especially if it is one-off. Getting into arguments only worsens the situation and may harm your reputation.
Example: Rujuta Diwekar, a well-known Indian nutrition author, gracefully responds to critiques by discussing her research and addressing misconceptions without being defensive. This approach enhances credibility. Similarly, J.K. Rowling, the author of the Harry Potter series, has faced numerous negative reviews but has always responded with grace and professionalism, focusing on the positive impact her books have had on readers.
4. Find Strength in Positive Reviews
Remember, you will also receive positive book reviews. Use these to remind yourself why you wrote the book in the first place. One, two, or even a few bad book reviews should not deter you. Instead, focus on the joy of storytelling, just as Ruskin Bond does. His approach to criticism is a great example of how to stay motivated and confident in your writing.
Action Step: Keep a folder of feedback and work on the actionable reviews.
5. Use Criticism to Improve
Instead of dwelling on negative feedback, channel it into improvement. Many Indian authors fine-tune their writing based on constructive criticism and return stronger.
Example: Sudha Murthy’s writing was once critiqued for being too simple, but she embraced her unique style. Today, her books resonate with millions.
6. Keep Writing and Stay Confident
Remember, your mental health is just as important as your writing. Bad book reviews should not deter you from writing, but it’s also okay to take a break and focus on self-care when you need it. The trick is to focus on the positive reviews, learn from constructive reviews and keep writing. With every book, polish your craft. Keep in mind, even the best authors face critical book reviews. It is how you handle bad book reviews that matters
Example: Devdutt Pattanaik’s unique take on mythology wasn’t always met with instant acceptance, but his dedication led to a loyal readership.
How to Handle Bad Book Reviews: Dos & Don’ts
| Do’s | Don’ts |
|---|---|
| Read reviews with an open mind | Engage in arguments |
| Separate constructive feedback from hate comments | Take criticism personally |
| Use valid points to improve your writing | Dwell on negativity |
| Stay professional and dignified in your response | React impulsively on social media |
| Focus on positive reader engagement | Let one review define your success |
Final Words: Transform Criticism into Growth
A negative review is merely one person’s opinion—it does not define your talent or success. Accept feedback gracefully, keep writing, and continue sharing your voice with the world.
Call to Action: Have you ever dealt with bad book reviews? Share your experience in the comments! Let’s inspire each other to handle criticism like true storytellers.
Every writer dreams of their book being embraced with praise, but what happens when the critics aren’t so kind? How to handle bad book reviews gracefully is an essential skill for any author. The Indian literary scene, rich with diverse voices and sharp critics, has seen its fair share of harsh reviews, but also inspiring comebacks.
Helpful Reading
Best Book Influencers in India
Top Book Reviewers in India: A Comprehensive Guide
Discover more from ZorbaBooks
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.